You Know What Happens When You Assume, Don't You?: Book Review of Reckless

 

Reckless by Lauren Roberts

Gratitude

Thank you to Montgomery County Public Libraries for making Reckless by Lauren Roberts available to the public at no cost.

Description

Reckless begins in the aftermath where Powerless left off: Paedyn is on the run, Kitt, now king, is furious, and Kai is unsure how to feel about any of it. Kitt sends Kai (who is his Enforcer first and his brother a far second) to find Paedyn and bring her back to the palace. There is no guarantee that Kai will be successful in his mission.

Would I Teach This Book?

Would I teach this book? Reckless has many of the challenges that Powerless has: Kai is meant to be an assassin, and his main job is to eradicate the kingdom of all Ordinaries, the people without powers who have been falsely accused of passing a disease on to the Elites, those who do have powers. Falling in love with a man whose mission in life is to unquestioningly kill people like you does not seem like a healthy choice.

It is made clear, just as it is in Powerless, that Kai is a product of his environment--his father tortured him and taught him to torture others. He was expected to kill and he knew that if he did not, the consequences would be dire--perhaps death. Regardless of how sympathetic he is, he still murders as commanded, and therefore, does not make healthy boyfriend material. You can feel sympathetically toward the dog who has been abused, and you can see how fun it is to play with him, but that does not mean that it is on you to bring the dangerous creature home as your pet. Kai might have had no control of how his father raised him, but that does not mean that Paedyn needs to take on a man who was created to kill her.

Sorry not sorry, but no matter how attractive the MMC is, whether or not it is his fault or not, if he has dangerous emotional baggage, the FMC does not need to take him and his exploding, poisonous luggage on her journey. It seems that sometimes when everything in you says that you should run, then you should run, regardless of your attraction. Just saying. And this does not seem to be the romantic situation that should be served to young readers, over and over again.

The sequel is also significantly lighter on plot than Powerless. The romance is a lot less convincing and a lot less satisfying. So, no, I cannot see myself teaching Reckless.


View all my reviews

Wash That Man Right Out of My Hair: The Women of the Copper Country

 

The Women of the Copper Country by Mary Doria Russell

Gratitude

Thank you to Montgomery County Public Libraries for making The Woman of the Copper Country by Mary Doria Russell free and readily available to the public.

Description

The Women of the Copper Country is based on the true story of a copper miners’ union strike in Calumet, MI. As copper mining is extremely dangerous, all of the women have lost people close to them--fathers, brothers, husbands--sons. They do not own their houses and have very little to live off of. When the one-man drill comes into use, they are not only worried about the jobs that it will cost, but also about the danger to the man operating the drill--a man alone can get into as many troublesome spots as a man with a partner, but a man alone has no one to help him out of those spots.

When a non-union worker who agreed to use the drill dies alone, Annie Clements decides that enough is enough. The strike is on.

James McNaughton does not see himself as the villain--he sees himself as the man hired to make the company--and himself--the most amount of money possible. He views the strike as ungratefulness. It is by his benevolence alone that the miners and their families are able to survive.

Would I Teach This Book? 

Would I teach The Women of the Copper Country? Russell’s book was a book club pick, and I doubt I would have picked it up on my own. My take on the book is a little different from my fellow club members. The general consensus was that they had seen this book before in other iterations that they had read in the book club, before my time. As I had not been present for those books, and I generally do not pick up historical fiction books independently, this book did not feel like something I had already read.

Annie is difficult to dislike--she has a big heart, courage, and a can-do attitude. She wants the lives of the people in her community to be fair--they should be able to work safely, and they should have the means to live a slightly less strenuous life. She believes in their right to negotiate as a group.

In a class on historical fiction, the labor movement, or gender studies, The Women of the Copper Country could be a contender. The terrible forces that the unions were up against, and the way that the companies were able to act as they wanted without regulation is hair-raising. I know some about the fight for labor, but I did not know the extent of it. The difficulties that people went through so that workers today can have the ability to collectively bargain is nearly unbelievable. And it's a story that Americans should know. 

View all my reviews

Home, Home with the Ranger: Book Review of The Ruins of Gorlan

 

The Ruins of Gorlan by John Flanagan

Description

In John Flanagan's The Ruins of Gorlan Will has been a ward of the kingdom since his birth, keeping him separated from most children his age. He was told his father died a hero, and he clung to the hope that he, too, would become a knight. But Will does not have the brawn a knight needs, and instead is invited to become the apprentice to a ranger.

Will is devastated. The rangers do not carry the same honor as knights, though they are feared, and rumored to be sorcerers. One of his wardmates—a constant tormentor—is sent to battle school, furthering Will’s upset. Since he does not have much say in the matter, he decides to do his best as the ranger’s apprentice.

As it turns out, the rangers gather intelligence and help in battles. They are the defense before war—and no one is eager to tread back into war. They hide in the shadows and make it their business to know the movements of enemies.

Soon, Will finds out that there is a lot more to being a ranger than scrubbing the floor—though his master has him do that, too.

Would I teach this book? 

The Ranger’s Apprentice: The Ruins of Gorlan is the first in a middle grade series. Many educators seek to get their students into series, with the thought that they will read their way through. If I were giving students a few choices of books, I might consider including it in a unit. There is action, and Will is a strong character, as is Horace, who has a parallel story line while he is in battle school. I was not blown over by the premise—the setting is a medieval-ish land that seems to follow the rules of reality, with the exception of some monsters. It reminded me a lot of Blackthorn Key, but I was more interested in the background of Blackthorn Key. It did come highly recommended from one student, so it may pique the interest of others. Definitely a good choice for a classroom or child’s library.

View all my reviews

Spit in the Air, Learn a Lesson: Book Review of Just After Sunset

 

Just After Sunset by Stephen King

Gratitude

Thank you to the Montgomery County Public Libraries for making Stephen King’s Just After Sunset easily accessible to the public at no charge.

Description

Just After Sunset came out in 2008, when the world, as they say, was a different place. No worldwide pandemic, smartphones weren’t a thing yet, and September 11th was the tragedy of the generation. Accordingly, some of the stories show a reality that is far from where we are today. In particular, “The Things They Left Behind” focuses on September 11, 2001, and is from the point of view of a character who worked in the Twin Towers, but did not go in that day. The freshness of September 11th is so different from now, when anyone under thirty probably has no memory of that day.

The story, in Stephen King fashion, has an element of the supernatural--office belongings from his coworkers show up in his apartment, out of nowhere. The hauntings, however, do not seem to serve the same purpose as they do in other stories--for example, another story in the collection, “The Cat from Hell” visits with what seems to be malicious intent.

King also touches on mental health in a few stories, questioning perceptions of reality and our individual lives, as well as personal rituals and compulsions. In King’s stories, a trick of the mind can trap us in a hell we didn’t know we were capable of creating.

The stories in this volume are not King’s strongest short fiction. There aren’t any of his richly detailed novellas. The characters do not have significant backstory or development. Even the plots do not take the reader on the same adventure as many of his other stories. They seem to have begun with obvious “what would happen if” scenarios that do not transcend above the original question.

Would I teach this book?

Of all the many works in King’s catalogue, including other collections of his shorter works, Just After Sunset just doesn’t burn as brightly. For fans, it is a reasonable read, but as a point of discussion showcasing the depth and breadth of his work, I would not include it on the syllabus.

View all my reviews

Come Out, Come Out, Wherever You Are: Book Review of Finding Dorothy

 

Finding Dorothy by Elizabeth Letts

Description

Finding Dorothy by Elizabeth Letts tells the story of Maud Baum, daughter of suffragist Matilda Gage and wife of L. Frank Baum, author of The Wonderful Wizard of Oz. Maud is a force to be reckoned with—even as a child, she won the neighborhood boys’ coveted marbles, climbed trees, and wore her brother’s hand-me-down britches to keep her from being slowed down by skirts. She was not the typical girl growing up in the 1860s, as she learned once she started college and found herself particularly irritated by the teasing of the boys and the double standards for female students.

While a student, she met Frank, an actor and proprietor of a theater company. She is taken by his whimsy and imagination. Her mother warned her whole life that a woman’s choice of husband dictates the rest of her life, so Maud is cautious with him at first.

Being told alongside the narrative about Maud and her life with Frank is the tale of Maud’s efforts to represent Frank in the making the film version of The Wizard of Oz. The movie was one of the first technicolor movies and made Judy Garland’s career. It was also made after Frank had died, and Maud had promised him that she would look after his vision. To that end, she persistently visited the movie studio until she forced her way onto set and into meeting the cast and crew of the movie, including a teenaged Judy. Maud soon learns that no one is looking out for the young star and Hollywood is far from a safe place for girls.

Would I teach this book? 

Finding Dorothy was a book club pick, and it generated a lot of conversation. Maud is a strong character and she comes across on the page as vibrant and forward thinking. There are plenty of Easter eggs about where different ideas from The Wonderful Wizard of Oz originated.

The book could be taught as an interesting study of research and fictionalized accounts of real life people. It could lend itself to a potentially lively conversation about the creative liberties taken and the line between historical fiction and creative nonfiction. To that end, it would potentially be a good place to begin that conversation. However, we have read other novels in book club which do similar work and are better written.

Finding Dorothy has the added appeal of giving an impression of a young and vulnerable Judy Garland. Maud is notable for being the wife of a famous author. Without these connections, the book would not be nearly as interesting.

View all my reviews

You Broke My Heart, Fettuccini: Book Review of The Godfather

 

The Godfather by Mario Puzo

Gratitude

Thank you, Montgomery County Public Library, for making The Godfather by Mario Puzo readily available to the public at no cost.

Description

In The Godfather, Puzo constructs a world in which when the system seems unfair for the little guy, he doesn’t need to wait for the heavens to supply justice in the afterlife, because he can appeal to Don Corleone to right the wrongs in this life. On earth, his godfather, Don Corleone, will help when all else fails. The Godfather will punish the boys who attacked his daughter, and also help the widow, the local boy who made it big, and the baker, while making sure that everyone gets a cut.

Don Corleone started as an immigrant who worked hard, but observed that another person’s power move could tip the balances—for example, a demand for protection money might change how a business operates, to the detriment of the guy at the bottom. Once he understands the way things work, Corleone decides that he will do what it takes to provide for his family, and if that means establishing his own mafia family, so be it.

Don Corleone’s sons, Sonny, Fredo, and Michael grow up in their father’s shadow. Sonny, the oldest, is hotheaded and the youngest, Michael, is defiant, enlisting in the army against his father’s wishes. Fredo, the middle boy, does not have the strength of his brothers. Connie, the baby of the family and the only daughter, is pampered and adored. The book opens on her wedding.

As with any good mafia man, Corleone’s influence is far reaching. He has many politicians in his pocket and informants in different areas, including the police department. The other families are on the look out for a weakness in the Corleone family to exploit, and they just might find one.

Would I teach this book?

Would I teach The Godfather? The Godfather has an interesting structure. It is split up into eight different books that move around from the past and story present, including telling parts of the story line from different characters’ points of view, without becoming repetitive. Puzo creates a family epic that both endears the reader to the Corleone family at the same time as laying bare the twisted morality it operates under.

In following the book’s structure and many characters, there is a lot to learn about making a simple plot line complex and creating a seemingly fantastic world within our own. To that end, it would be a good book to study in order to learn more about writing an entertaining plot. It is not high literary writing, but, as many bemoan, a lot literary novels do not put their strongest emphasis on plot. So, yes, The Godfather could be an instructional tool to that end and may also create a desire in a new generation to watch the trilogy of movies it spawned.

View all my reviews

Why Don't You Write a Letter to the San Juan Star?: Book Review of The Correspondent

 

The Correspondent by Virginia Evans

Gratitude 

Thank you to the Montgomery County Public Libraries for making The Correspondent by Virginia Evans available as a lucky day book.

Description

Sybil Van Antwerp comes from another time, when there were few female judges, and to find a way to influence the court system, she spent her career clerking for a well-known judge. Sybil’s relationship with him was a working one only, but they were the closest of collaborators. She did not just advise him, they made decisions together, and to hear it told, on equal footing. Around the time the judge dies, Sybil also begins to experience deteriorating eye sight, and her already limited amount of travel shrinks even further.

Sybil communicates with the world largely through letters. She corresponds with her family and friends as well as some well-known authors, such as Joan Didion. Like Didion, she lost a child, though Sybil’s Gilbert died when he was only eight. Sybil still feels the loss with a terrible intensity that continues to impact her life in many ways. The letters include a lot of her backstory, and in an interesting way that does not slog down the plot.  

The Sybil we meet brokers no fools, as the saying goes, nor does she make departures from her quiet life, at least not easily. She can be hard and difficult, but she can also be thoughtful, caring, and willing to put up a good fight for anyone for whom she cares.

Would I teach this book? 

Would I teach The Correspondent? In a time when letters are way out of fashion, Virginia Evan’s The Correspondent may be one of the last modern-day epistolic books that is not fully emails. In fact, the author has Sybil defend her letter writing to other characters.

The book is not terribly long, which is helpful for teaching–the longer a book, the more difficult to include on the syllabus. It has a good story and great character development. It might not be as amazing as some might be claiming, but it is an enjoyable read. It is a possibility to be included in a creative writing or literature course, but it would not be in my top ten or even top twenty picks.


View all my reviews